Build Plainly

What Is a Bill of Quantities, and How Homeowners Can Use One to Compare Builder Quotes

Updated · 6 min read

Key points

  • A bill of quantities lists each item of work with a description, unit and measured quantity, so every bidder prices the same thing.
  • UK bills are usually measured to RICS NRM 2, while North American estimates rely on quantity takeoff, commonly organized by CSI MasterFormat.
  • A priced bill lets you compare quotes line by line and gives agreed rates for valuing changes.
  • A schedule of works lists tasks, often without measured quantities, and a lump-sum quote gives one price with the quantities hidden.
  • Small, simple jobs are commonly priced from drawings, a specification and a schedule of works rather than a full bill.

A bill of quantities turns a set of drawings into a measured list of everything needed to build them, so that competing builders price exactly the same work. Knowing how one works makes any builder's quote easier to read and to question.

This article is general information, not financial or contractual advice. For a specific project, a quantity surveyor or cost consultant can advise on the right approach.

What a bill of quantities is

A bill of quantities (BoQ, or BQ in RICS documents) lists the items that make up a building, each with a description precise enough to identify it and a measured quantity. That is close to how the RICS rules for detailed measurement, NRM 2, define it.

The bill has two jobs. Before the contract, it gives every bidder the same list to price, so builders compete on price rather than on their own reading of the drawings. After the contract is signed, the priced bill becomes a contract document and the basis for valuing work done for interim payments and for valuing changes, usually called variations.

In traditional UK procurement the bill is prepared by the client's quantity surveyor (QS) or cost manager. Under design-and-build arrangements, where the contractor takes on the design, the contractor or its specialist subcontractors usually do the measuring instead.

How a bill is structured

A full bill has several parts. The main ones for a homeowner are:

  • Preliminaries: costs not tied to one piece of work, such as site set-up, management, security and safety.
  • Measured works: the body of the bill, listing every item of work with its quantity.
  • Provisional sums: amounts set by the QS for work that is expected but not yet designed. NRM 2 separates defined provisional sums, where the nature and extent of the work are known, from undefined ones, where they are not.
  • Summary: totals carried from each section to a single tender figure.

Measured work can be grouped by building element (substructure, superstructure, finishes and so on), by work section (broadly by trade, such as masonry or carpentry) or by work package (the way the work will be split between contractors).

Each line in the measured works has the same parts: an item reference; a description of the material, size and position (NRM 2 reminds surveyors that the bill is a legal document, so descriptions must leave no doubt); a unit, such as linear meters (m), square meters (m²), cubic meters (m³), number (nr), tonnes (t) or a single item; the quantity measured by the QS; the bidder's rate per unit; and the amount, which is quantity multiplied by rate.

The measurement rules behind it

United Kingdom: RICS NRM 2

The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) publishes the New Rules of Measurement. NRM 2, Detailed measurement for building works, covers bills of quantities; its second UK edition took effect on 1 December 2021. Its tabulated rules cover 41 work sections, from preliminaries and demolitions to mechanical and electrical services, setting out what is measured, in which unit, and what each description must state. A bill measured to NRM 2 should say so.

United States and Canada: quantity takeoff and MasterFormat

In North America the measuring step is usually called a quantity takeoff. A Penn State construction management textbook describes the unit-price approach: identify the unit of measure for each item, carry out a detailed takeoff to find the quantity, then apply unit costs for materials, labor and equipment, with overhead and profit either built into the rates or added separately. On commercial projects these estimates are typically organized by CSI MasterFormat categories.

MasterFormat is a classification and numbering system maintained by the Construction Specifications Institute (CSI) and Construction Specifications Canada. It is used across North America so that drawings, specifications, estimates and product data describe the work in the same terms. The current edition is MasterFormat 2026.

Australia

The Australian Institute of Quantity Surveyors (AIQS) publishes the Australian and New Zealand Standard Method of Measurement of Building Works (ANZSMM). Government clients may specify a particular edition: Western Australia's government guidance for its own building works names the earlier Australian Standard Method of Measurement, 6th edition (March 2016), with local amendments, as the method quantity surveyors must use when measuring for bills of quantities.

Bill of quantities, schedule of works or lump-sum quote?

  • Bill of quantities: Measured by the client's QS to a standard method. Every bidder prices identical quantities, so differences lie in the rates, not the measurement.
  • Schedule of works: A list of the tasks to be done. It may carry quantities (NRM 2 also covers quantified schedules of works) or none, in which case each bidder has to measure from the drawings. UK small-works contracts are built around this: guidance for the JCT Minor Works contract describes a lump sum priced from drawings, a specification and/or work schedules, without detailed measurements and without the client providing bills of quantities.
  • Lump-sum quote: One price for the whole job, based on the builder's own takeoff. The bottom line is easy to compare, but the quantities and assumptions behind it are hidden. Even a lump sum can move: the JCT Minor Works guidance, for example, adjusts the price for changes to the work and for work instructed against provisional sums.

A worked example

The table below is an example only, using illustrative round numbers in no particular currency. It does not reflect market prices.

RefDescriptionUnitQtyRateAmount
1Plasterboard ceiling, 12.5 mm, fixed to timber joistsm²2030.00600.00
2Softwood skirting board, 120 mm high, primedm4010.00400.00
3Internal door set, hollow core, 826 × 2040 mmnr3200.00600.00

These three lines total 1,600.00. The QS supplies everything up to the quantity column; each bidder fills in the rates, and the amounts follow.

Using a priced bill to compare quotes

  1. Send every bidder the same bill and ask them to price every line, not just the total.
  2. Check the arithmetic. Each amount should equal quantity times rate, and section totals should carry correctly to the summary.
  3. Compare line by line. With identical quantities, any gap between bids comes from rates or preliminaries. If one builder prices the ceiling at 30.00 per m² and another at 45.00, ask both what they have allowed for.
  4. Question blanks and "included" entries. Under NRM 2, preliminaries costs that a contractor does not itemize are treated as having no cost or as included elsewhere in its rates, so clarify gaps before accepting a bid.
  5. Set provisional sums aside. They are fixed by the QS, not the bidder, so they are the same in every bid and do not separate one bid from another.

The accepted rates then become the yardstick for changes. In the example above, if the ceiling grows from 20 m² to 25 m², the extra 5 m² at the agreed 30.00 adds 150.00. NRM 2 notes that the firmer the bill, the better it works for cost control, because the direct cost of a change can be assessed against the bill rates. With an approximate bill, the quantities are remeasured once the work is done.

When a full bill is overkill

A full bill takes a quantity surveyor's time, and that fee has to be weighed against the size of the job. NRM 2 itself allows for approximate bills where the time or cost of a firm bill is not warranted, and JCT's Minor Works contract is designed for simple jobs priced without bills; its guidance says it is not suitable for complex works.

For a bathroom refit or a single-room alteration, a proportionate approach is clear drawings, a written specification and a schedule of works, with every builder asked to price the same schedule line by line and to state the rates they would use for changes. A full bill earns its cost on larger or more complex projects with several bidders, where consistent pricing and control of changes and payments matter most.

Frequently asked questions

Who prepares a bill of quantities?

In traditional UK procurement, the client's quantity surveyor or cost manager measures the drawings and prepares the bill before tenders are invited. Under design-and-build arrangements, the contractor or its specialist subcontractors usually do the measuring instead.

What is a provisional sum?

It is an amount the quantity surveyor includes for work that is expected but not yet designed well enough to measure. RICS NRM 2 distinguishes defined provisional sums, where the nature and extent of the work are known, from undefined ones. The contract price is later adjusted to the value of the work actually instructed.

Is a schedule of works the same as a bill of quantities?

No. A bill measures every item to a standard method so all bidders price identical quantities, while a schedule of works lists the tasks and may give no quantities at all. UK small-works contracts such as JCT Minor Works are designed to be priced from drawings, a specification and/or work schedules without a bill.

How are quantities organized in US and Canadian estimates?

Estimators carry out a quantity takeoff, measuring each item in its unit of measure and applying unit costs for materials, labor and equipment. On commercial projects the estimate is typically organized by CSI MasterFormat, the classification system maintained by CSI and Construction Specifications Canada.

Sources

  1. NRM 2: Detailed measurement for building works, 2nd edition UK (2021) — RICS
  2. MasterFormat 2026 — Construction Specifications Institute
  3. Unit Price Cost Estimating, Fundamentals of Building Construction Management — Penn State (John I. Messner)
  4. Cost Planning Method of Measurement — Government of Western Australia
  5. Australian and New Zealand Standard Method of Measurement of Building Works (ANZSMM) — Australian Institute of Quantity Surveyors
  6. Minor Works Building Contract with contractor's design 2016: Guidance Notes — Joint Contracts Tribunal

This article was researched from the sources listed above and drafted with AI assistance, then checked against those sources and approved by an editor before publication. It is general information, not professional advice for your project. Read our editorial policy, or tell us about an error.